For $100 - 150 / built like a tank gear, I don't think too many people would argue with a used McKenney glove.
They are certainly available for that price and last and last. Certainly not ultra light / and certainly not lacking protection.
Here is the only one on ebay at this time - sized Pre-Lockout
NEW McKenney Instinct 855 Goalie Catcher Blu/Wht/Sil - eBay (item 360052834112 end time May-22-08 14:33:38 PDT)