I cant comment on the V1's as i never owned a pair..
but i can say that the smith catcher is one of the best i have ever owned.
No popouts and no stingers.. none..
This glove is simply one of the best i have ever owned/used.
the blocker is well balanced.. and protective no issues..
After a couple of years of use the only thing i needed to do to it was replace the inner plastic piece which was cracked by Jr A slapshot.. damn kids
I can shoot very well with these gloves.. they do not feel clumsy or bulky at all..
My 2 cent.. order them use them.. if you hate them sell them in the classifieds or ebay.. because like most gear.. its tough to judge them unless you use them personally..
any other questions simply call pete..he answers the phone himself and is a great guy to talk hockey with!!
cheers
Jim